The Well-Tempered Ear

Classical music review: Haydn’s “The Creation” is filled with brilliant light and sound by the Wisconsin Chamber Choir and the Stoughton Chamber Singers | April 5, 2011

By Jacob Stockinger

By one local critic’s count, Haydn’s “The Creation” has been performed only three times in the past 35 years or so in Madison.

That is too bad for one of the all-time great masterpieces of oratorio and choral writing.

But at least, it seems, when it is performed it is generally performed very well.

Certainly such was the case with last Saturday’s outstanding performance of “The Creation” by the 45-member Wisconsin Chamber Choir and the 18-member Stoughton Chamber Singers with soloists and a fine 31-piece pick-up orchestra drawn from local groups (all below).

These are not high-profile groups in a city filled with so many fine classical music ensembles. But perhaps this kind of performance could bring them a bit more publicity and a higher profile. It certainly should.

As Isthmus critic and retire UW history professor John W. Barker (below) pointed out during his crowded pre-concert lecture, Haydn’s oratorio was the prolific composer’s single most worked on piece by the great composer of 104 symphonies. And it stands squarely in the middle of the oratorio tradition, looking backward to Handel and forward to Mendelssohn and others.

Everything about the performance, which just got better and better as the singers and instrumentalists progressed and warmed up, seemed appropriate.

Even the venue fitted the piece. It was performed in the Masonic auditorium (below), on Wisconsin Avenue, near the state Capitol, and Haydn was a Mason in Vienna for two years. The concert hall itself seems an intimate space with good acoustics, and one wishes it were used more often.

True, the performance was not sold-out. But it was a very good size crowd and an enthusiastic one.

I found the singers and instrumentalists particularly good at the many moments of sound painting used in the score: the bright voices bringing light to chaos; the strings portraying the first dawn of the first day; the flute-made bird calls; the trombone hoof beats of galloping animals; and the double-bass lumbering of great whales.

All sections performed well, but I was particularly struck by the brass (hard instruments to play), the winds and by the constant but never flagging fortepiano continuo provided by Theodore Reinke.

At times the orchestra seemed a bit loud for the chorus, but the balance of the well matched groups improved as the performance progressed.

But of course, it was the vocalists – soloists and choirs alike – who rightfully reigned over this creation of “The Creation.”

Some standouts included soprano Deanna Horjus-Lang as the angel Gabriel (bel0w, second from right), who voice often soared effortlessly. Both tenor J. Adam Shelton as Uriel and bass Brian Leeper (below, second from left) as Raphael proved excellent narrators, whose excellent diction allowed us to hear the English text and who sang with both lyricism and an assertive seriousness.

As the newly created Adam and Eve, bass Michael Roemer (below, right) and soprano Madeline Olson (below, left) somehow embodied innocence through their young and lighter voices. The duo seemed perfectly matched to my ears.

All of this is a great compliment to Robert Gehrenbeck (below top), the Wisconsin Chamber Choir’s artistic director since 2008, who held the performance together with the appropriate tightness that deserved the standing ovation it got (below bottom).

If the work itself seemed less expressive than one might imagine, well that is one of the great contrasts between Haydn and the emotionally deeper Mozart, to whom he is so often – and so unjustly — compared.  The underlying belief was the religion of Reason and the Enlightenment, not the profundity of a personal statement, even though Haydn was a devout a Roman Catholic.

In any case, Haydn (below) considered “The Creation” his best work. And to sing it with comparable conviction is not an easy task. But it is one that was fulfilled by this performance, which brought a lot of light of its own to this often-neglected masterwork and to a dark and irrational time.

But don’t take just my word for it.

Here is the fine review by John W. Barker of Isthmus:

What do you think of Haydn’s “The Creation”?

What do you think of this performance?

The Ear wants to hear.


Posted in Classical music


  1. Hi, Jake,

    Thank you for the intelligent, supportive commentary and excellent photos. I only knew a couple of the choruses from The Creation, prior to this performance, and it was a wonderful surprise to discover such a wide range of writing styles within this work. In that way, it reminds me of the encyclopedic B Minor Mass by Bach; The Creation boasts everything from baroque counterpoint to elegant, charming Rococo to moments of mystery and rapture which feel positively Romantic and beyond.

    I have nothing but profound admiration and respect for Dr. Gehrenbeck’s artistic vision, and energetic diligence in bringing this off so well. I applaud the WCC’s dedication to the high-quality presentation of the concerted choral works of Bach, Handel and now Haydn.

    What a gift to the community. Please keep it up!

    Comment by Marika Fischer Hoyt — April 5, 2011 @ 2:15 pm

    • Hi Marika,
      Bravo — you said it all.
      I look forward to more performances of different form the same people.

      Comment by welltemperedear — April 5, 2011 @ 3:36 pm

Leave a Reply to Marika Fischer Hoyt Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 1,158 other followers

    Blog Stats

    • 1,923,632 hits
%d bloggers like this: