The Well-Tempered Ear
Is a lot of ‘woke’ music inferior to the music it replaces?
12 Comments
PLEASE HELP THE EAR. IF YOU LIKE A CERTAIN BLOG POST, SPREAD THE WORD. FORWARD A LINK TO IT OR, SHARE IT or TAG IT (not just “Like” it) ON FACEBOOK. Performers can use the extra exposure to draw potential audience members to an event. And you might even attract new readers and subscribers to the blog.
By Jacob Stockinger
Is a widespread attempt to explore historically ignored music and overlooked, marginalized composers interfering with the public hearing greater, more important and more beautiful music?
It is a problematic but timely question or issue, especially during an era of political correctness and in our current culture wars.
To be sure, you can hear some memorable music that has unjustifiably been excluded from the so-called canon. The discovery of Florence Price (below) is a prime example. The same can be said for Clara Schumann.
It does seem that a lot of the newly rediscovered pieces and composers — Black, Hispanic, Indigenous, Asian, women, LGBT — deserve an initial hearing, if only out of curiosity and to correct the historical record.
But after being heard for the first time, many of them seem second- or third-rate. They deserve to be shelved for another few decades in favor of restoring greater music and greater composers to the active performing repertory.
To The Ear, for example, the symphonies by Michael Haydn always sound inferior to those of his famous older brother Joseph. And it doesn’t matter what critics and audiences of the day said, history its often — if not always — the better judge. The symphonies and violin concertos of the impressive and influential Joseph de Boulogne (Chevalier de Saint-Georges, below) are simply not as artistically interesting or engaging as those by his contemporary Mozart.
Anyway, whatever you think, The Ear came across an essay on the internet by George Leef that was published in The National Review — the iconic conservative political magazine founded by William Buckley. It contains background about current nationwide programming guidelines and organizations that you might not know.
It is an interesting point of view. It often goes over the top and clearly overstates the case against “woke” repertory by accusing those who support it of being “enemies of classical music” rather than sincere and well-intentioned progressive advocates of artistic justice.
But it deserves a serious reading and a serious answer to the provocative question of balancing the great and the less great. Here is a link:
Read it for yourself and make up your own mind.
Then please tell The Ear and other readers what you think in the Comment section.
The Ear wants to hear.
Tags: #Blackcomposers, #BlogPost, #BlogPosting, #ClaraSchumann, #FacebookPost, #FacebookPosting, #FlorencePrice, #RacialDiscrimination, #TheEar, #TheInternet, advocate, artistic, Arts, Asia, Asian composers, beautiful, Beethoven, bias, black, blog, Chevalier de Saint Georges, Clara Schumann, Classical music, composer, concerto, conservative, culture wars, discrimination, Ethnicity, explore, Facebook, first-rate, Florence Price, Franz Joseph Haydn, gay, gender, great, Haydn, History, iconic, Indigenous, indigenous music, inferior, intention, Internet, Jacob Stockinger, Johann Sebastian Bach, Joseph de Boulogne, justice, lesbian, LGBT, LGBTQ, link, Ludwig van Beethoven, male, marginal, Michael Haydn, Mozart, Music, organization, political, politically correct, Politics, progressive, public, race, racist, repertoire, repertory, second-rate, sex, Sexism, share, sincere, symphony, tag, The Ear, The National Review, third-rate, Violin, Website, white, William Buckley, woke, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, women
Classical music: The Madison Symphony Orchestra opens its new season with a strong and memorable concert that had something for everyone — with no outside help from a guest artist
4 Comments
IF YOU LIKE A CERTAIN BLOG POST, PLEASE SPREAD THE WORD. FORWARD A LINK TO IT OR, SHARE IT or TAG IT (not just “Like” it) ON FACEBOOK. Performers can use the extra exposure to draw potential audience members to an event. And you might even attract new readers and subscribers to the blog.
ALERT: On this Saturday, Oct. 5, from 4 to 5 p.m., cellist Amit Peled will teach a master class at Farley’s House of Pianos, 6522 Seybold Road, near West Towne Mall, where he will instruct local students. This is a FREE event that the public is invited to observe, and is part of the two concerts by Peled and pianist Daniel del Pino. For more information, go to:
By Jacob Stockinger
Many orchestras, including the Madison Symphony Orchestra (below, in a photo by Peter Rodgers), often use the opening concert of a new season as a chance to lure audiences by wowing them with some big-name guest soloist.
But last weekend maestro John DeMain (below, in a photo by Greg Anderson) once again preferred to show off his own ensemble. And it worked, making for a memorable concert.
The MSO opener had something for everyone, and what you saw as the highlight probably depended more on your personal taste or preference than on the overall impressively tight playing and singing of the MSO, its principals and its chorus.
It seemed clear that, for most listeners the MSO’s young organist Greg Zelek (below, in a photo by Peter Rodgers) filled the role of the impressive imported star or guest artist.
The virtuosic Zelek is simply so good that he managed to turn a second-rate piece by Samuel Barber into a first-rate crowd-pleaser that brought huge applause and a long standing ovation, then an encore and another standing ovation.
As music, the concerto-like “Toccata Festiva” (1960) is simply not on par with Barber’s Violin Concerto or his Adagio for Strings or his Overture to “The School for Scandal.” It is 15 minutes of mostly loud and bombastic music meant to show off the new organ that it was commissioned for.
The King of Instruments seems to invite such bragging. And the boyish, vest-clad Zelek milked the score by Barber (below) for all it was worth, including an astounding three-minute cadenza played only with the feet. It’s hard to argue with such dramatic success.
If you preferred more serious fare, there was the Symphony No. 7 in D minor by Antonin Dvorak (below). Last spring, DeMain announced his fondness for Dvorak – in the spring the MSO will perform his Requiem.
DeMain’s feeling for Dvorak showed in a convincing and engaging performance of this darker, non-programmatic Brahmsian work that goes beyond the Czech folk dances, folk song-like melodies and nature mimicry of Dvorak’s other major symphonies and chamber music.
If you wanted exciting Romanticism, it would be hard to beat Wagner’s rhythmic strings soaring in the Overture to the opera “Tannhauser” by Richard Wagner (below). And that flowed into Wagner’s sensual “Venusberg” music that featured the MSO chorus singing offstage.
But The Ear thinks that the best measure of musicianship – orchestral, instrumental or vocal — is not how loudly they can play or sing, but how softly.
For that reason, he found the standout work at the concert to be “Prelude to The Afternoon of a Faun” by Claude Debussy (below). The balance among various sections proved ideal at expressing subtlety. You could hear everything combining to make a distinctive and atmospheric tonal color.
For example, it is hard to imagine more sensual playing of the opening theme than how principal flutist Stephanie Jutt (below) did it. The performance and interpretation projected the exact kind of impressionistic seductiveness that the composer meant for it to have. For sheer beauty of sound, it took the top spot. (You can see a graphic depiction of Debussy’s score in the YouTube video at the bottom.)
Still, there seemed to be more than the usual number of empty seats. Was it the rainy weather? The football weekend? Or do people still miss the thrill of hearing a well-known guest artist opening the season?
What do you think?
What was your favorite piece on the opening MSO program? And why?
The Ear wants to hear.
Tags: #AdagioforStrings, #AmitPeled, #AntoninDvorak, #BlogPost, #BlogPosting, #BlogReview, #ChamberMusic, #ChoralMusic, #ClaudeDebussy, #CommissionedMusic, #Czechcomposer, #DanieldelPino, #FacebookPost, #FacebookPosting, #Farley'sHouseofPianos, #FolkDance, #FolkMelody, #GregZelek, #GuestArtist, #GuestSoloist, #JohannesBrahms, #JohnDeMain, #KingofInstruments, #MadisonSymphonyChorus, #MadisonSymphonyOrchestra, #MeadWitterSchoolofMusic, #OrchestralMusic, #PersonalTaste, #PopularSuccess, #PreludetotheAfternoonofaFaun, #RichardWagner, #SamuelBarber, #StandingOvation, #StephanieJutt, #SymphonyOrchestra, #TheEar, #TheSchoolforScandal, #UniversityofWisconsin-Madison, #VenusbergMusic, #ViolinConcerto, #VocalMusic, #WestTowneMall, #YouTubevideo, Adagio for Srtrings, Amit Peled, Antonín Dvořák, applause, Arts, astounding, atmosphere, audience, balance, blog, bombastic, Brahmsian, cadenza, cellist, Cello, Chamber music, chance, Choir, choral music, chorus, Classical music, classicalmusic, Claude Debussy, color, commission, commissioned music, composer, Concert, concerto, crowd, Daniel del Pino, dark, Debussy, depiction, drama, Dvorak, empty, encore, ensemble, event, express, Facebook, fare, Farley's House of Pianos, feet, flute, folk dance, folk song, folksong, fondness, football, free, graphic, Greg Zelek, guest artist, guest soloist, hear, highlight, impressive, instrument, Jacob Stockinger, Johannes Brahms, John DeMain, King, king of instruments, loud, Madison, Madison Symphony Chorus, Madison Symphony Orchestra, Maestro, master class, masterclass, Mead Witter School of Music, measure, melody, memorable, mimicry, minute, Music, musicianship, nature, new, offstage, opener, opera, orchestral music, organ, organist, Overture, personal, personal taste, Pianist, Piano, playing, pleaser, popular, post, posting, prefer, preference, Prelude to the Afternoon of a Faun, principal, public, rain, Requiem, Richard Wagner, Romanticism, Samuel Barber, score, Season, seats, second-rate, sensual, serious, show-off, singer, Singing, song, Spring, standing ovation, Stephanie Jutt, strings, subtle, subtlety, success, symphony, symphony orchestra, Tannhauser, taste, test, The Ear, The School for Scandal, theme, thrill, tight, toccata, tonal, United States, University of Wisconsin-Madison School of Music, University of Wisconsin–Madison, UW-Madison, UW-Madison Mead Witter School of Music, Venusberg, Violin, Violin concerto, virtuosic, virtuoso, vocal, vocal music, Wagner, weather, weekend, West Towne Mall, Wisconsin, work, worked, worth, YouTube
Recent Comments
The Well-Tempered Ear 