The Well-Tempered Ear
Classical music: Singer David Daniels is accused of drugging and raping a young opera singer
1 Comment
By Jacob Stockinger
More allegations of sexual misconduct and sexual assault keep emerging from the world of classical music, even as the #MeToo movement is again in the headlines with accusations and denials about the movie star Asia Argento having sex with a minor.
The latest allegation is an accusation by a young opera singer who says that in 2010 he was drugged and raped by David Daniels (below), who is world-famous as a countertenor and who teaches at the University of Michigan, where he is now on leave.
Included in the allegation is Daniels’ husband Scott Walters, who is a conductor and who is accused of participating in the drug and rape incident.
Here is a well-researched and well-reported story from National Public Radio (NPR):
https://www.npr.org/2018/08/22/640945881/opera-singer-david-daniels-accused-of-rape
And here is a link to the story in The New York Daily News, the newspaper that first broke the story. That version also has photos of the accuser and Scott Walters.
Tags: #AsiaArgento, #DavidDaniels, #MeToo, #MeToomovement, #MetropolitanOpera, #NationalPublicRadio, #NewYorkCity, #OperaMusic, #OperaSinger, #OperaStar, #OrchestraConductor, #Same-sexmarriage, #samesexmarriage, #SantaFeOpera, #ScottWalters, #SexualAbuse, #SexualAssault, #SexualHarassment, #SexualMisconduct, #TheMet, #TheNewYorkDailyNews, #UniversityOfMichigan, #World-famous, accusation, allegation, Arts, Asia Argento, Baroque, choral music, Classical music, Compact Disc, conductor, countertenor, denial, drug, drugged, Early music, film, George Frideric Handel, headlines, husband, Jacob Stockinger, Madison, minor, movie, Mozart, Music, New York City, Newspaper, NPR, opera, photo, rape, raped, reporting, research, Same-sex marriage, Santa Fe Opera, sexual abuse, sexual assault, sexual harassment, singer, star, symphony, the Met, The New York Daily News, United States, University of Wisconsin-Madison School of Music, University of Wisconsin–Madison, vocal music, Wisconsin, world
Classical music: Two new memoirs and a new recording are revealing but uneven in marking the centennial of Leonard Bernstein
2 Comments
By Jacob Stockinger
We are only a month away from the centennial of the birthday of conductor, composer, educator and pianist Leonard Bernstein, which will be celebrated on Saturday, Aug. 25. Larry Wells, who is The Opera Guy for The Ear, recently assessed three of the many works – two new books of memoirs and one new recording — reexamining the life, career and legacy of Leonard Bernstein.
By Larry Wells
During this year commemorating the centenary of the birth of Leonard Bernstein (below, in a photo by Jack Mitchell), one need only consult https://leonardbernstein.com to find a day-by-day calendar of performances of his works.
As well as world-wide opportunities to hear his works -– even in Madison — there have been two recent books about Bernstein and a new recording of his final opera, “A Quiet Place,” that might be worth your time.
“A Quiet Place” was premiered in Houston as a sequel to his earlier opera “Trouble in Tahiti.” These first performances were conducted by our own John DeMain, the longtime artistic director of the Madison Symphony Orchestra and music director of the Madison Opera.
This nearly two-hour one-act opera dealing with incest, bisexuality, alcoholism and psychosis did not please the critics either for its libretto or for its music.
Soon thereafter Bernstein refashioned the opera by inserting “Trouble in Tahiti” in the middle and cutting some music. His subsequent recording has always baffled me because the music is so uninteresting and the casting is so haphazard.
The new recording on the Decca label (below) is of yet another version devised by Garth Edwin Sunderland. Reducing the orchestration to a chamber ensemble of 18 players, removing “Trouble in Tahiti,” and restoring some of the cuts, this recording by Kent Nagano and the Montreal Symphony Orchestra allows us to hear most of the original version of the opera.
(To read Sunderland’s analysis of his edition, check https://leonardbernstein.com/uploads/pages/files/PFR_2013_FW.pdf.)
The new recording is a valiant attempt by Nagano (below) to breathe some life into this dreary work, but I remain unconvinced that “A Quiet Place” is any more than a failed, final stab by a composer most of whose work I admire very much.
Charlie Harmon was Bernstein’s personal assistant, and his recent memoir ”On the Road and Off the Record with Leonard Bernstein: My Years with the Exasperating Genius” (below) goes a long way in explaining the failure of “A Quiet Place.” (You can hear the Postlude to Act I of “A Quiet Place” in the YouTube video at the bottom.)
To hear Harmon tell it, by this time in Bernstein’s life the maestro depended on drugs to go to sleep, drugs to keep himself awake, and alcohol in excess. He also had a penchant for younger men.
The picture he paints of a troubled genius is rather pathetic, and Bernstein comes across as thoughtless, self-centered and exasperating. When Harmon (below, on the right with Bernstein) writes of his shock at being groped by Bernstein, I had to wonder what else he had expected. Still, it is an entertaining read.
Bernstein’s daughter Jamie Bernstein has recently published “Famous Father Girl: A Memoir of Growing Up Bernstein” (below) Here we get a glimpse into Bernstein’s family life. The portrait of his troubled relationship with his long-suffering wife Felicia Montealegre is particularly interesting.
I heard Jamie Bernstein (below) speak recently in Tucson, and she told amazing anecdotes about Aaron Copland, Samuel Barber and William Schuman.
Little of that appears in the book. She assumes that the reader is interested in her own love life and her failed pop music career. I would have preferred to read more about the many fascinating people who surrounded Bernstein and less about her privileged and entitled life.
I have always been a big fan of Bernstein. I admired him as a conductor, teacher and composer. Anyone who has even a nominal interest in the man will find both of the recent memoirs at least diverting. The recording of “A Quiet Place,” however, is only for the true devotees.
Tags: #AaronCopland, #AQuietPlace, #ChamberEnsemble, #CharlieHarmon, #DeccaRecords, #DrugsandAlcohol, #FamilyLife, #FeliciaMontealegre, #GarthEdwinSutherland, #JohnDeMain, #KentNagano, #LeonardBernstein, #LoveLife, #MadisonOpera, #MadisonSymphonyOrchestra, #MentalIllness, #MontrealCanada, #MontrealSymphonyOrchestra, #MusicEducation, #OfftheRecord, #OntheRoad, #OriginalVersion, #PersonalAssistant, #PopMusic, #PrivilegedLife, #SamuelBarber, #SexualHarassment, #SleepingPills, #TroubleinTahiti, #TucsonArizona, #WilliamSchuman, #YoungMen, #YouTubevideo, A Quiet Place, Aaron Copland, alcohol, alcoholism, anecdote, AODA, Arizona, Arts, bisexual, bisexuality, Book, calendar, Canada, cast, casting, centennial, Chamber music, Charlie Harmon, choral music, Classical music, Compact Disc, composer, conductor, daughter, day, devotee, drugs, educator, Family, genius, Houston, husband, incest, interest, Jacob Stockinger, Jamie Bernstein, John DeMain, Kent Nagano, Leonard Bernstein, LGBT, LGBTQ, life, Love, Madison, Madison Opera, Madison Symphony Orchestra, man, memoir, Montealegre, Montreal, Music, off-the-record, opera, Orchestra, original, pathetic, performance, personal assistant, Pianist, Piano, player, pop, psychosis, psychotic, record, recording, relationship, road, Samuel Barber, self-centered, Sleep, suffering, symphony, Teacher, Texas, thoughtless, troub;e, Trouble in Tahiti, Tucson, United States, University of Wisconsin-Madison School of Music, University of Wisconsin–Madison, version, vocal music, wife, William Schuman, Wisconsin, young men, YouTube
Classical music: What should — and shouldn’t — the #MeToo movement mean for women in the opera world?
11 Comments
By Jacob Stockinger
It is clear now that just about all aspects of life and culture in the United States are being affected more and more by the #MeToo movement that seeks to expose, punish, correct and prevent sexual harassment, sexual misconduct, sexual assault, sexual abuse and gender inequality in general.
But what does that mean specifically for the notoriously patriarchal and misogynistic opera world – meaning for the operas themselves and their themes, plots, characters and composers as well as for the people who put them on?
How, for example, should one now think of “Don Giovanni” by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart? (The womanizing Don Juan is seen below in a production of “Don Giovanni” by the Metropolitan Opera.)
A recent discussion on National Public Radio (NPR) covered many dimensions of the problem, and The Ear found what was said fascinating although he didn’t agree with everything.
One Italian production went so far as to change the ending of a famous and popular opera – Bizet’s “Carmen” — in order to redeem the doomed heroine.
That seems excessive to The Ear, something that recalls the 17th-century writer Nahum Tate who rewrote the tragedy “King Lear” by Shakespeare to give it a happy ending. (You can hear the original ending of “Carmen” in the YouTube video at the bottom. The 2009 production by the Metropolitan Opera features Roberto Alagna and Elina Garanca.)
It brings up the question: How far should one go in imposing contemporary values on the past? And does rejecting an artist also mean rejecting that artist’s work?
Read the edited transcript or listen to the entire 8-minute discussion for yourself. Besides the female host (Lulu Garcia-Navarro), three women – two singers (Aleks Romano and Leah Hawkins) and one administrator (Kim Witman) – ask questions and give their opinions and thoughts.
Here is a link to the story that was posted on the NPR blog “Deceptive Cadence”:
Then decide what you think you would like to see done to address the concerns of the #MeToo movement in the opera world, and what is allowed and not allowed to you.
And let us know in the COMMENT section.
The Ear wants to hear.
Tags: #AleksRomano, #ArtisticWork, #DeceptiveCadence, #DonGiovanni, #DonJuan, #ElinaGaranca, #GenderInequality, #GeorgesBizet, #HappyEnding, #KimWitman, #KingLear, #LeahHawkins, #LuluGarcia-Navarro, #MeToo, #MeToomovement, #MetropolitanOpera, #NahumTate, #NationalPublicRadio, #OperaComposer, #OperaWorld, #OriginalEnding, #RobertoAlagna, #SexualAbuse, #SexualAssault, #SexualHarassment, #SexualMisconduct, #TheMet, #UnitedStates, #WilliamShakespeare, #WolfgangAmadeusMozart, #YouTubevideo, administrator, America, artist, Arts, Baroque, blog, character, Classical music, composer, contemporary, culture, discussion, Don JUan, ending, famous, George Frideric Handel, hero, heroine, Italian, Italy, Jacob Stockinger, life, Madison, Madison Opera, Metropolitan Opera, misogynistic, misogyny, Mozart, Music, New York City, NPR, opera, Opinions, original, patriarchal, patriarchy, plot, popular, production, question, rewrite, singer, the Met, theme, thoughts, tragedy, transcript, U.S., United States, University of Wisconsin-Madison School of Music, University of Wisconsin–Madison, values, vocal music, Wisconsin, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, womanizer, work, world, YouTube
Recent Comments
The Well-Tempered Ear 
Classical music: The opera world is divided over accusations of sexual harassment against superstar tenor Placido Domingo. Here is how John DeMain reacted. How do you react and what do you believe?
4 Comments
IF YOU LIKE A CERTAIN BLOG POST, PLEASE SPREAD THE WORD. FORWARD A LINK TO IT OR, SHARE IT or TAG IT (not just “Like” it) ON FACEBOOK. Performers can use the extra exposure to draw potential audience members to an event. And you might even attract new readers and subscribers to the blog.
By Jacob Stockinger
By now, you have probably heard about the allegations of sexual harassment recently made anonymously against the still-active superstar Spanish tenor Placido Domingo (below), 78, who holds the record for the most opening-night appearances at the Metropolitan Opera.
What you might not have heard is how divided the opera world is over those accusations, which are now being formally and independently investigated.
Much of that division falls along lines of Europe versus the United States. The former has so far not cancelled upcoming appearances while the latter was quick to. And Domingo has been defended by famed Russian soprano Anna Netrebko (below, with Domingo).
In the wake of the #MeToo movement, sexual misconduct and sexual assault continue to be perhaps the most controversial issues amid many similar or more serious criminal allegations against conductors James Levine, Charles Dutoit and Daniele Gatti as well as many teachers and orchestra players.
Perhaps the best account of the divided reactions came in a story from The New York Times. Here it is:
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/08/18/arts/music/placido-domingo-opera-harassment.html
One sign of the difficulty in dealing with the situation can be found in the carefully worded, balanced and empathetic Facebook comment by maestro John DeMain, the music director of the Madison Symphony Orchestra and the artistic director of the Madison Opera.
DeMain has often worked with Domingo, perhaps most notably in the famous 1992 Concert for Planet Earth in Rio de Janeiro, which DeMain conducted. (You can hear Domingo singing an aria by Puccini and see DeMain conducting the orchestra in the YouTube video at the bottom.)
Says DeMain (below in a photo by Prasad): “Thinking about the Placido Domingo controversy. While I’m not in a position to take sides in this very sad situation, I would just like to say that in my many interactions with this great tenor over many decades, I personally never witnessed him do anything that was inappropriate. He was always a kind and gentle person to me and my family. I wish him and his family well through this difficult time.”
Here is a link to DeMain’s Facebook page if you would like to read comments from others or leave one of your own: https://www.facebook.com/jldemain
How do you react to the accusations?
What do you believe should happen to Domingo?
The Ear wants to hear.
Share this:
Like this:
Tags: #AnnaNetrebko, #BlogPost, #BlogPosting, #CharlesDutoit, #ConcertforPlanetEarth, #CriminalBehavior, #DanielGatti, #FacebookPage, #FacebookPost, #FacebookPosting, #GiacomoPuccini, #JamesLevine, #JohnDeMain, #MadisonOpera, #MadisonSymphonyOrchestra, #MeToo, #MeToomovement, #MetropolitanOpera, #OpeningNight, #OperaMusic, #OperaWorld, #OrchestralPlayers, #PlacidoDomingo, #RiodeJaniero, #RussianArtist, #SexualAssault, #SexualHarassment, #SexualMisconduct, #SopranoSinger, #SuperstarSoprano, #SuperstarTenor, #TenorSinger, #TheEnvironment, #TheNewYorkTImes, #TheU.S., #UnitedStates, #VocalMusic, #YouTubevideo, accusation, allegation, Anna Netrebko, anonymous, appearance, aria, Arts, audience, balance, balanced, blog, Brazil, cancel, cancellation, Charles Dutoit, Classical music, comment, Concert, Concert for Planet Earth, conduct, conductor, controversial, crime, criminal, criminal behavior, criminal justice, Daniele Gatti, decades, defend, difficult, divided, Earth, empathetic, empathy, environment, environmentalism, Europe, event, Facebook, Facebook page, fame, Family, formal, gentle, Giacomo Puccini, great, hear, inappropriate, independent, interaction, investigate, investigation, issue, Jacob Stockinger, James Levine, John DeMain, kind, law, legal, Madison, Madison Opera, Madison Symphony Orchestra, Maestro, me, Me Too, Me Too movement, Metropolitan Opera, movement, Music, opening night, opera, opera world, Orchestra, page, person, personal, planet, player, Plácido Domingo, post, posting, Puccini, reaction, record, Rio de Janiero, Russian, sad, see, sexual assault, sexual harassment, sexual misconduct, side, sing, Singing, situation, soprano, Spain, Spanish, story, subscriber, superstar tenor, tenor, The New York Times, time, U.S., United States, vocal music, witness, word, worded, work, world, YouTube